my first photo post

[QuisutDeus]

This was originally shot in color. I converted it to B/W in PhotoShop Elements. I adjusted the contrast for the clouds and sky. Any constructive criticism would be nice.

[casil403]

I really like this....the contrasts in the clouds and the whole photo work for me...well done.

[Mad Aussie]

A slightly bigger shot makes it easier for us to critique but this looks good to me as well. Composition looks nice, as does the contrast.

I can only offer a small suggestion I think and that's the composition might have been stronger if you'd have moved to your left and only included about half of the dead tree. I think this would have removed the messy looking lower left part of this shot and created an interesting framing in the process.

[Bambi]

I would love to see the colour version too!

However, my only addition is that to crop off the bottom part of it to eliminate the roots. When I scroll down it makes it stronger for me.

but that's being nit-picky. I really like it!

[QuisutDeus]

I saturated the color photo a little.

[Bambi]

I agree with you that B&W was the way to go. I think that the crop works too. My only other piece of advice would be to clone the sign out. But nice work!

[Mad Aussie]

I'm wondering what the sign says now I can see there's a sign in there

Generally we find something around the 700 to 800x600 size works well.

[JAS_Photo]

It's got a real Ansel Adamsy feel to it.

[Marko]

I like this new cropping and prefer the b/W - (nice size).

There's still lots of room here for additional dodging and burning which will help this sing even louder.

[Fortytwo]

Same for me here, the b&w is much better.