Camping Sunsets

[tegan]

WOW Kiley....... I'd take that and run.... it's not easy getting props from old mr. grumps... I believe I am still waiting for the pleasure.... Good on ya!!

Hey, I am not that old, but I have seen one heck of a lot of totally outstanding photos, so my judgement directly relates to that experience.
By the way, I apply the same pickiness to my own work too. :

Tegan

[tegan]

I very much like that 2nd shot as well Kiley - (though I thing the first one is superior.)

Come on, Marko. I am sure you will agree that the second shot has much more depth from both the reflection and the sky than the first one and depth is an absolute requirement to avoid a FLAT looking shot.

Tegan

[tegan]

I really like the first one
good job

The first one has great colour and great sky detail and exposure but more dark area and less detail than number 2 overall and that is the important difference.

Tegan

[kiley9806]

Come on, Marko. I am sure you will agree that the second shot has much more depth from both the reflection and the sky than the first one and depth is an absolute requirement to avoid a FLAT looking shot.

Tegan

funny, i thought the 1st boat shot had more depth due to the tree in the foreground... i think it is that tree that makes me prefer the 1st shot...

...
*edit*
ok, wait. i re-looked, and can see what you mean by the 'depth' in the reflection & sky.

[kiley9806]

I really like the first one
good job

were you meaning the 1st shot of the batch?
or the 1st shot the 2 boat angles?
(and thank-you!)

[tirediron]

Wow, not sure how I missed these. Absolutely top-notch! Sunsets are without a doubt, one of the most overdone subjects in photography, but you've got a group here that is the equal of any I've seen in a very long time. Really excellent work!

[tegan]

funny, i thought the 1st boat shot had more depth due to the tree in the foreground... i think it is that tree that makes me prefer the 1st shot...

...
*edit*
ok, wait. i re-looked, and can see what you mean by the 'depth' in the reflection & sky.

OOPS, I meant the first shot of the batch..the red one with the great sky..not the first boat shot.

Perhaps numbering shots in future would help avoid confusion... Just a thought.

Tegan

[Marko]

Awww man - I had written up a good rebut to your edited statement tegan,

Originally Posted by tegan
Come on, Marko. I am sure you will agree that the second shot has much more depth from both the reflection and the sky than the first one and depth is an absolute requirement to avoid a FLAT looking shot.

Tegan

and then you took it all away by saying we are talking about different shots. Damn computer freezing before I could post...

I guess it's all good then
and nice work again Kiley!
marko

[tomorrowstreasures]

LOOOOVVVEEEEE these!

[tomorrowstreasures]

Kiley - these are wonderful!!!