Flower in color and BW

[Yisehaq]

Dear All,
Please tell me which one works for you? Any other C&C is most welcome as well.

[MoinMoin]

Oh - I prefer some colour on these loveley roses! So far you've presented them in a fine way. But I would choose a much smaller frame and I would give the left blossom a tit bit more space. Hope that helps?

[Yisehaq]

Thanks for your comments MoinMoin

[Odyssey]

Colour version for me

[jlabel]

I really loved the black and white one, the left flower seems a bit greenish pink to it and its weird, and the background has a blue tinge to it, tho its just me

[Marko]

Nice shot! - I'm with JL here, BW all the way.
The green leaves compete too hard with the actual flower heads and the blue window is a slight distraction for me.
If this were mine I'd try to up the contrast on the flower heads and sharpen their centers just a wee bit more.

[Matt K.]

Nice shot! - I'm with JL here, BW all the way. ... If this were mine I'd try to up the contrast on the flower heads and sharpen their centers just a wee bit more.

Ditto, monochrome works wonders in this shot.

[Yisehaq]

Thank you all for your comments! Based on your inputs I have tried to further processed the BW. What dyal think?

[Mad Aussie]

Personally I like colour version best. For me, for a flower shot to special in B&W it needs some very good lighting and textures going for it. Perhaps shape too. Without that, a flower is all about colour for me.